Saturday, May 26, 2007 - Posts

Eve Misconduct - CCP Story Rather Leaky

The initial, official CCP response to the allegations regarding CCP Sharkbait and his surreptitious assumption of the role of director in a Goonswarm corporation is that he was investigating a bugged Player Owned Structure (POS) at the request of the owner corporation itself, Darkstar1.

That would seem like him off the hook.

Except that the CEO of Darkstar1 sheds some light on this:

"Statement on dev misconduct:

for the record, Darkstar1 has 3 pos in game only, both are and have always worked fine and have never been petitioned by anyone in the corp for not working, the statement given by CCP is incorrect and simply not true,

LUCASWV, - CEO of Darkstar1"

Allowing for the fact that he doesn't know enough English to know that "both" and "all" are not synonymous (we have a lot of foreigners in Something Awful, and so in Goonfleet and our allied corporations), this is a pretty damning statement.  Especially viewed in conjunction with his reports of the immediate deletion of his petition, and the refusal to escalate it to managerial level.

If nothing else, CCP sure are dumb.

Eve Online Scandals - Some More Evidence

Well, at least one of the three alleged scandals turns out not to be alleged at all.  Dianabolic has never been the smartest tool in the shed, and faced with allegations that BoB players are able to call directly on CCP developers and complain to them or have in-game features changed, Dianabolic's repsonse is "well, obviously!"

Here are some pictures of his postings, capturing this for those of you understandably unable to bring themselves to enter the Eve-Online forums.  If your monitor can't display them in a high-enough res on this page, right-click and use "open in new window" from your context window.  apologies for what it does to my right navbar, but I don't have time to change my css settings for megapictures right now!

Dianabolic 1 Dianabolic 2 Dianabolic 3

I think someone needs to learn when to stop talking and shut up rather than boasting about how close you are to the developers.  If CCP are wise they'll say "we've tried keeping responsible links, it doesn't work.  All contact must now be official and logged."

In another development, corroborating evidence has emerged of the scandalous removal and blacklisting of Raekhan, the ISD reporter who BoB demanded be removed using the links Dianabolic admits to having, above:

Admiral_Chamrajnagar: ok anyone know an ISD named rekan?
Macayle: why?
[IC]Raekhan: I'm right here.
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: you need to leave that system
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: you are making an ass of yourself
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: and of ccp
[IC]Raekhan: ?
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: enticing the player base is not actions that you want to do
[IC]Raekhan: What..are...you....
[IC]Raekhan: ?
Cortes feels a facepalm coming on
[EA]Aristaqis: enticing? Was he putting on a strip show or something? [IC]Tsuki facepalms
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: the local player base asked him to politly stop pushing dreads
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: that were undergoing a siege operation
[IC]Raekhan: I was not pushing a dread.
[IC]Raekhan: I'm 70KM away.
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: it does not matter.. posting in local "no"
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: and that "your not going away"
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: and that all you hear is "static"
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: and to complain to eris discordia
Admiral_Chamrajnagar: is not helpfull at all
Cortes: which wouldn't do much good given I'm the IC VA

To make this clear, the "Admiral" is an Eve database admin who has just received an MSN messenger IM from Orange Species, a member of BoB, demanding that Raekhan be removed.  I imagine that database admins are not usually supposed to involve themselves in community discipline, as well as the management of Eve CCP's voluntary employees in the ISD division. To recap, Raekhan's boss immediately reported this action to Internal affairs, who discovered that the Admiral character was a CCP employee then promptly fired Raekhan, as well as removing all his associated rights and player account, and have refused to answer any queries or petitions regarding what happened.

And to prove who Admiral Chamrajnagar is?  Here is another screenshot, which I'll only link to in order to save on leeching the bandwidth of the poster:

http://freenet-homepage.de/winchip2/2007.02.16.18.19.49.PNG

What you see there is the same Eve developer, Chamrajnagar, coincidentally in-system when BoB destroyed a logged-out D2 titan worth over a thousand dollars, congratulating them on what they had done.  His comments are in blue on the left, his profile is centre-page, showing that he is a database admin.




Eve-Online Dramabombs

The initial response by CCP to the allegations of widespread corruption of the last 24 hours has been interesting.

Clearly, they have learned from the mistake made in handling previous dramabombs.  This time, after taking down the forums, they posted this news item, acknowledging that the accusations have been made.  That's a good thing, and suggests a degree of transparency.  That the person who posted it is CCP Arkanon, head of CCP's Internal Affairs team, set up after the T20 dev-cheating scandal (when a CCP developer caught cheating was essentially excused for his actions, despite their immense potential effect on the gameworld).

On the downside, only one of the three allegations is mentioned in that item, and there seems to be a degree of prejudice here, in that before the Internal affairs department - themselves implicated in the scandal regarding improper BoB-ISD contact - has investigated the suggestion is made that the developer involved was probably just doing his job.  I, too, were I in his position, would find some sort of semi-believable reason to act before making such an outrageous move.

While CCP Sharkbait and the potentially illicit corporate transactions he carried out (and about which all petitions were locked and deleted, and any attempt to escalate refused - so "just doing his job" sounds fishy at best) might well be the most vital in terms of immediate effect, it is the fixing of events, and the ability of BoB members to have ISD employees threatened and, ultimately, fired that I find most unpleasant.  It, yet again, points to a culture of involvement between certain players and CCP as an organisation that is at best hugely unprofessional, and at worst downright corrupt.

One neutral (non-Goonfleet) poster said it best last night in a now-locked thread: if CCP just admitted up-front that this is their sandbox, which they run largely for their own benefit, and that the choices were reduced to "Eve - love it or leave it" then such frankness would, at least, not leave such an unpleasant stench of petty, grubby corruption in the nostrils.

If anyone feels that they are of strong-enough character to descend into the nine levels of hell which are the Eve-O forums, then a discussion thread has been allowed by CCP: another wise move, and another lesson learned from the T20 scandal.  If nothing else, it leaves their board moderators only one place to look.

PS - Rather disappointingly, I seem not to have got myself a ban.  Some on the Goonfleet forums are proudly flaunting their pariah status.  How I envy them.